On
Monday morning I worked out the chords for “Rocking Chair” by Serge Gainsbourg.
I did some reading on efforts to
bring about Indigenous self-government in Canada.
I took an early siesta so I would be
fresh for Indigenous Studies class this afternoon.
Even though the snowstorm had come
and gone two days before it was still somewhat treacherous for a bicycle. There
was a traffic jam on Brock Avenue I waited five minutes before walking my bike
around an SUV that was too close to the curb.
I took it easy along College because
the covered areas pushed me out almost to the streetcar tracks. I usually turn
left on Huron to get to the Ramsey-Wright Building but after the previous storm
it was less clear and a lot more slippery than the side streets in Parkdale.
Instead I went one block east and rode up St George to Wilcox, then walked from
there. There was a wall of snow separating me from the bike post rings in front
of the building. But half of the closest ring was sticking out through a snow
bank and so I leaned my bike on the bank and only chained the lower part of the
frame to the stand.
White told us that the instructions
for our outline, abstract and full assignment are posted on Quercus. There are
abstract examples posted as well and the proposal must be 150 words. The
outline needs to be sufficient to tell where we are going, what we are thinking
about and why. Try to answer something. We are not locked in only to the
outline. The final draft is due on March 16. We also have a reflection paper
that’s due on February 10 or 17. The abstract outline had been due next week
but now it’s die on February 10.
He told us that he was going to stay
close to the podium because he was going to try to record the lecture for us.
He asked us what we thought of
Belanger’s chapter on Political Organizing.
UNDRIP is the United Nations
Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People. Canada, the United States,
Australia and New Zealand all at first abstained from signing in 2007 but came
on board later when the wording was changed.
The argument began in 1924 when Levi
General Deskaheh brought Iroquois concerns before the League of Nations.
UNDRIP, like the Truth and
Reconciliation Commission does not have teeth.
The UN was struggling with the
wording and at first had wanted to use the word “populations”. Indigenous
people found that offensive and so it was changed to “people”.
White complains that Yale Belanger looks at Indigenous people as one
group. I haven’t seen that. In every page of the book he refers to different
nations.
In the 1920s Levi was denied entry
into Canada. The Jay Treaty of 1794 allows Canadian Indigenous people to live,
work and trade in the United States, but when restrictions were placed on
Indigenous people travelling the treaty was not honoured on the Canadian side.
White seemed to think that there’s a
toll to cross the border but that’s only where there are bridges with tolls.
Some Indigenous people are to some extent exempt from paying border bridge
tolls.
The US is getting stricter at the
border because of Trump. People are being asked for their citizenship.
Clinton Rickard was a Tuscarora
chief known for founding the Indian Defence League and promoting North American
sovereignty. He worked for free passage of Native Americans across the US
border. There is an annual parade across the Rainbow Bridge in his honour and
people from both sides of the border meet in the middle.
He showed us a video of the meeting
in Geneva in 1977 of one hundred Indigenous delegates from North and South
America. They were representatives of twenty million people and were there to
draw attention to issues of nationhood, self-determination, land rights, the
environment and genocide. The event was a United Nations Conference on
Discrimination Against Indigenous Populations in the Americas. The speaker in
the video is Oren Lyons.
White says Lyons asked, “Where is a
seat for the bear at this gathering?”
Indigenous land was communal. The
Europeans thought of land as private property. But to be fair, at the time of
first contact there was still a fair amount of communal land all over Europe,
including England. The peasants of Europe had not much more of a concept of
owning land than the Indigenous people of North America.
The Royal Proclamation is important
for Indigenous people because it says that only the crown has the right to buy
land from Indigenous people and then to transfer it to settlers.
The United States Constitution
recognizes Indigenous treaties as more important because they came before.
The 1823 Marshall Trilogy took away
nationhood in establishing the government controlled and therefore owned the
land.
The Wet’suwet’en Nation in Northern
British Columbia is occupying Unist’ot’en Camp to block the construction of a
Coastal GasLink pipeline between Chetwynd and Kitimat. Elected chiefs and five
band councils had signed an agreement to allow the pipeline but the hereditary
chiefs say no. Two house chiefs supported the pipeline but then were stripped of
their titles by the other chiefs. The argument is that the pipeline is planned
to go through land unceded by the nation. White says Trudeau said, “Too bad”
but I assume he was interpreting. Trudeau has said, “I understand your
frustration. We will work together to resolve these issues.” It seems very
strange to me that a Social Scientist would say something as if it’s a quote
when it isn’t.
In 1924 the Haudenosaunee wampum
belts held in Ohsweken were confiscated by the RCMP to force a band council
style government on the people of the Grand River.
White says Belanger doesn’t talk
about 1964 in Canadian Indigenous activism but I can’t find any reference to
anything happening in 1964 even on Indigenous activist websites.
In 1992 in South America there was a
big event commemorating the 500th anniversary of Columbus’s arrival.
It was billed as co-existence and there was no mention of conflict.
Is it legal or ethical to take
people’s land?
The right of occupation is not the
same as title. Renters are occupants while owners can do pretty much what they
want. He said he could have had a chicken coop in Rochester but didn’t find out
until he left.
The superintendent general
controlled an Indigenous person’s life from cradle to grave. They were wards of
the state.
The mayor of Rochester offered
Mohawks a building for a dollar. It was a dump but a lot of Indigenous people
work as contractors. They couldn’t get it because of generational conflicts.
There was no tax exemption.
Assimilation was the goal. Trade
land for civilization.
Treaties are about renewing
friendships. NAFTA is not the only treaty between Canada and the US.
White read a 1925 speech by Levi
General Deskaheh. Outlines: Nearly everyone listening is a paleface ...
Europeans might have gotten a quarter of the land fairly if they’d tried ... We
would rather you kill us than assimilate us … You got votes for women from us …
We had no jails …
White is a lousy reader.
There is a reference to Irish
Americans in the speech because in the 1920s the Irish had been dehumanized.
There was open discrimination.
The oldest league of nations founded
by Haudenosaunee.
If not for Indigenous people the
French would have won Canada.
Elected forms of government were
forced on Indigenous people.
There were five different
governments in White’s community on both sides of the border.
A pass system was enforced in some
communities.
A student said that any gathering of
Indigenous people is considered an act of war in Canada. I think that might
have been true at one time but I can’t find any reference to it happening
today.
Amanda Polchies of Elsipogtog First
Nation held an eagle feather against the RCMP in New Brunswick when they raided
their peaceful protest camp against fracking. She was arrested but the photo
went viral and became the symbol later on of the Idle No More Movement.
Yale Belanger doesn’t mention Levi
General Deskaheh.
“Basic Call to Consciousness” is a
collection of essays in which Iroquois leaders discuss the importance of honouring
the sacred web of life and describe the spiritual roots of their traditional
government and cultural practices. It’s from a Haudenosaunee perspective but
they reached out to others for input.
UNDRIP article four is pivotal:
“Indigenous peoples, in exercising their right to self-determination, have the
right to autonomy or self-government in matters relating to their internal and
local affairs as well as ways and means for financing their autonomous
functions.”
The NGO Conference attendees from
1977 still meet the UN regularly.
Indigenous people are community
based.
White says Belanger does a bad job
of talking about confederacies.
Self-determination is inherently
local.
The Canadian government is vetting
indigenous investors to delegitimize protestors. White says those Indigenous
investors are traitors. I wonder if he would say it to their face. The
investors think the best way to mitigate the environmental impacts of the
pipeline is to be owners that have a say in the projects. He speaks of them as
if they are being controlled by the government. Maybe it was their idea.
He asked if Canada has separation of
church and state. It’s relative. Canada has much more separation of church and
state than the United States. It can be seen in our abortion laws. Next to Cuba
and Uruguay, Canada is the least religious country in the Americas.
Lineage by nation is not recognized.
White doesn’t like Belanger's
protocols.
Indigenous people always had
meetings with agendas.
Everybody’s needs are different. The
Haudenosaunee were never interested in the Assembly of First Nations.
It is traditional to rest for at
least a day after travelling to a meeting. Even today people feel the need to
rest after travelling.
Belanger says past transgressions
were overlooked at meetings but White says they were addressed and resolved.
What are the responsibilities of
bills of rights? They are the same for Indigenous people.
Free speech does not allow you to
shout fire in a crowded place.
Silence is a control mechanism.
The constitution of the five nations
is the great law of peace. It’s the oral constitution of the Haudenosaunee
Confederacy.
Arthur Parker founded the Society of
American Indians from 1911 to 1923.
The Lakota Confederacy did not want
any one group in control.
White claims there are more old
growth forests in New York.
Unlike the English and French the
Dutch came here for trade rather than to build an empire.
The Haudenosaunee are not supposed
to have separate band councils on both sides of the border.
When the Iroquois Nationals lacrosse
team travelled to Israel their Haudenosaunee passport was accepted, but not in
England.
At tutorial my boots were dripping a
puddle but I didn’t see anyone else with water under their feet and so I wondered
if they’d teleported there.
Safia was late.
The loudest talkers with each other are always Robin and the other
Indigenous woman. They were talking about powwows and the only other guy in the
room asked if people drink at powwows. The said there is no drinking allowed
because when one is drinking the spirit leaves the body. But some people do
show up under the influence. Robin said it’s best to not drink for at least a
day before. Plus the dancer’s clothing is sacred because it’s for healing and one
shouldn’t touch it while drinking.
After fifteen minutes Robin got a text from Nicole telling her Safia
was on the way. But after half an hour she hadn’t arrived and so we all decided
to leave. She was apparently tied up at the dentist. She sent an email later
saying that no one was there when she got there but she didn’t say what time
that was.
As I rode south, Huron was treacherous as I expected it to be and
sometimes I had to use my feet to keep my balance. When I got down to Queen
there were spots where I had to walk as well if I wanted to stay away from
traffic.
I stopped at Freshco on the way home where I bought three bags of
cherries and two bags of grapes.
I had a late lunch of spicy black bean soup with a bowl of potato
chips.
I worked on typing my lecture notes.
For dinner I had my last three small potatoes, a chicken breast and
some gravy while watching Doctor Who.
Spoiler alert!
This story, taking place in 1903, centres on the famous inventor Nikola
Tesla. He is in his lab at Niagara Falls fixing his generator when a floating
orb appears and then a cloaked figure begins shooting at him. The Doctor
suddenly shows up to rescue Tesla and his assistant Dorothy Skerrit. They board
a train bound for New York on which the Doctor’s team are already passengers.
In New York there are protesters demonstrating against Tesla's alternating
current electrical experiments goaded by Tesla’s rival, Thomas Edison, who uses
direct current. The Doctor suspects Edison of being behind the attack in
Niagara Falls but when she goes to Edison's lab all of his employees are killed
by an electrical weapon. Tesla and Yasmine are teleported to an invisible
Skithra ship hovering above New York. The leader is the Scorpion Queen who
recognizes Tesla’s genius and wants him to fix her ship. All of her technology
is stolen and so she does not know how to repair it. The Doctor teleports in,
confronts the queen and then teleports her friends out. There’s a funny moment
when Tesla and Edison are arguing and Graham shouts, “Hey AC DC!" Tesla
and Edison help the Doctor use Tesla’s Wardenclyff Tower to transmit an
electrical blast at the queen’s shape and force her to leave Earth orbit.
Apparently when Tesla used to work for Edison, Edison offered $1000 to
anyone that could fix his generator. Tesla fixed it but Edison reneged on the
offer. In the Doctor Who story he says, “Tesla just doesn’t understand the
American sense of humour.”
It’s pretty sad that Tesla died penniless while Edison became rich from
buying other people’s patents.
No comments:
Post a Comment