On
Monday morning I posted my translations of both “Le complainte du progress” by
Boris Vian and “My chérie Jane" by Serge Gainsbourg on Facebook. The next
Vian song I'll translate is "On n'est pas là pour se faire
engueuler", which is a very jazzy swing tune.
I started looking for the lyrics for
“Les beaux lolos de Lola” (Lola's pretty titties). I found some but they seem
to have been taken from an incomplete video, which is the only video for the
song that I could find. I doubt if there is much more to the lyrics than the
ones I found.
At 9:30 I took an early siesta for
almost ninety minutes so I’d be fresh for class and wouldn’t have to sleep in
the late afternoon.
At 12:15 I left for Indigenous
Studies class.
I was the second student in the
room. The other one was the extremely well spoken middle-aged motorcycle mama
who’s somewhat fanatical about the course material. She acknowledged me with a
stern look when I said “Hi”.
I usually clean the blackboard
before class but I decided that Professor didn’t deserve the courtesy.
Safia, my TA came up to the front
and made an announcement about her tutorials, which, although she was speaking
to everyone, seemed to be directed at me.
She said there had been “difficult elements” disrupting the class and
claimed that some of the Indigenous students fled the class because of it. I
wonder if that’s really true and if they did was it really because of me? I
debated dispassionately with other students, including the Indigenous ones, the
way I’ve been trained to do as an academic. I never got the impression they
were upset about it. The only person that seemed to have a problem with me was
Safia because I committed the sin of disagreeing with her on a major part of
the course doctrine about colonial injustices, not nice things and ugly
histories. This was the idea she’d presented that residential attendance was
mandatory when it wasn’t. It certainly seemed to be preferred but it wasn’t
compulsory since there were government sanctioned day schools.
Safia declared that she is only
teaching the course the way it should be taught and if students don’t like it
that way there is no time to engage. No one student can monopolize the time and
take up space. This is funny because so much time is wasted by both Safia and
Professor White in rambling and not following a strict lesson plan. Tutorials
are supposed to have discussion and so she just means that there’s no time for
discussion that disagrees with the dogma of the course. Actually the students
that take up most of the time are two Indigenous women that tend start rambling
on about their personal lives. That’s okay with Safia because they are sort of
pets of the class. There has been a lot of difficulty getting Indigenous people
to take this course since it started years ago and so the Indigenous students
that do enrol seem to be coddled.
She said if we have issues we should
bring them up with the professor. I’ve learned first hand how that works out.
Associate Professor White began by
apologizing for it not having been a smooth fall session. He said he’s learning
beside us. That reminds me of the Simpson’s episode where Marge decides to give
piano lessons. The family says, “But you can’t play piano” but she says she
only needs to be one lesson ahead.
He confesses that he is a work in
progress.
He claims that his lectures include
some degree of discourse. Yes, as long as one doesn’t contradict the canon.
He said he’ll be streamlining the
course and trimming off some of the workload.
He said if this was his previous
school in the States he would scrap the syllabus and start over with a course
that we all agree upon. He says, “But Canadians love bureaucracy.”
One student spoke up to complain
that the course is too US-centric. The professor hadn’t even known what the
Toronto purchase was.
The professor gets defensive.
Robin, one of the Native students
says she wants to understand Ontario treaties and is also worried that the exam
will be US-centric.
The associate professor keeps saying
it’s a North American thing.
The student that mentioned the
Toronto purchase asks if White has taken any time to read up on it. He answers
that he is learning some of this stuff. He tells Robin that Canadian treaties
are a big learning curve for him. He reminds us all that we’ll have a chance to
evaluate him at the end of the year. I’m looking forward to it.
He excuses himself by saying we have
to learn together but defensively asserts that he doesn’t have time to learn it
all.
Robin confessed that she was
uncomfortable to approach him and backed down.
He says it’s a big adjustment to
teach a full year course after previously only teaching half courses.
He says our exam will have some
essay questions and some short answer questions. He’ll give us twenty-five
study questions and ten of them will be on the exam. Answering Robin he says
there will be some US content on the exam.
Another student tells him that we
don’t feel a connection with the US material. White argues that Thomas King’s The Inconvenient Indian is also US-centric. I don’t get
the point. King is not our professor and his book is not really a history book.
He says King has a laundry list shotgun style and so does Belanger, except that
Belanger assumes an air of authority. White is not satisfied with either of
them.
He asks how many of us know what
Truth and Reconciliation is. I think most of us do. What is RCAP? It’s the
Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples.
He asked us what is going on in the
news. He said there are two main issues. I thought of both of them but I didn’t
say anything. One is the pipeline protest that incorporates treaties and is also
about unceded land and sovereignty. What nobody guessed was the situation in
which the indigenous grandfather and twelve-year-old granddaughter were
arrested and both handcuffed while the man tried to open a bank account for his
granddaughter. He commented that Canada has more public awareness of Native
issues and yet such an arrest could still happen. He said this is the type of
Native issue that exists on both sides of the border.
White says the main issue in
unpacking all of this stuff is time.
The middle aged woman of South Asian
descent who sits behind me suggested that he bring in a guest speaker on
Canadian Indigenous Studies. He says that bringing in guest speakers wasn’t as
easy in the States. His excuse for not doing it is once again time and he says
he is stifled by the bureaucracy at U of T. She argues that he could pick a
week when his lecture slides are particularly US-centric and have a Canadian
speaker come in instead.
He says the marking system can’t be
changed without an agreement by a majority of students.
We have an assignment that’s due in
two weeks, which is an abstract and outline proposal for a reflection paper on
a topic of our own interest that’s due on February 10.
Near the end of the term we have to
do a media presentation in our tutorial.
The middle-aged biker said she wants
more anti-colonial criticality. White responded that he’d thought that had been
what he’d been doing all along.
He says he’s been an instructor for
twenty years. He confessed that sometimes he’s aloof.
He reminds us that in going to U of
T we are part of the colonial system.
Indigenous Studies are more than
history because it’s happening now.
He warns us that he would continue
to use a Haudenosaunee lens.
He says he doesn’t like how Belanger
handles the Métis.
All of this took up the first hour
of the class. Now he began the lecture.
The Métis have not been studied in
depth and they are oversimplified. It’s a complex history about territories,
language and communities. It is a mistake to conflate mixed genes with being
Métis.
He asked if Canada has an equivalent
to the Library of Congress. That would be the Library and Archives in Ottawa.
It’s the fourth largest library in the world.
White says that Louis Riel had no
children and so how can people claim to be descended from Louis Riel? He did
have children. It’s just that his two known children didn’t have children. But
he might have had sex with women outside of his two marriages and so there
could theoretically be descendants.
White says he once laughed at a
student who said she was she was descended from a Cherokee princess.
Johnny Depp was adopted by the
Chickasaw. It was the Comanche.
The Cherokee challenged blood
quantum by saying that if you can show you have a Cherokee family line then you
will be accepted as Cherokee.
The Red River is a place of
nationalistic identity for the Métis.
White didn’t know what HBC is. He
said Canadians love acronyms.
What is pemmican? It’s more than
dried berries and meat. It’s mostly dried crushed meat, dried berries and lard.
It’s not like jerky because it literally lasts forever. That doesn’t seem to be
true. It is generally said to last twenty years in the freezer but at the most
five years at room temperature. Some people claim that they’ve had
fifty-year-old pemmican. He says it’s something like the dried meals he had in
the army. The Haudenosaunee had their own version made with corn meal and dried
meat.
For the Métis the sale of pemmican
was an economic powerhouse that helped them maintain independence. The
government took it away. It seems to be mostly about competition because
certain settlers and companies wanted control of pemmican and didn’t want the
competition.
Does currency have value? It’s
really just a note. White declares that Canada’s debit system is to die for. He
complained about the $5 service charge. One can transfer money from savings to
chequing to avoid the charge. He says US banks don’t do that. I just carry
cash.
Most indigenous people had some type
of pemmican but with different names.
The trade system worked.
He says the Haudenosaunee were
notorious gamblers before contact. One might bet one’s wooden snow snake in a
game of snow snake. If you lost there was no debt because you handed over your
snow snake.
The middle-aged student with the
hand tattoo said that the Métis came from a female line. The pemmican was made
by women.
The French colonists purposely
created offspring with Indigenous women. But then the British took over and
they were less interested in mixing.
He says individual warriors might
stay home from a battle if they had a bad feeling and they weren’t judged for
it.
Large portions of what became Canada
were bought by the crown from a private company.
Some of the most racist communities
are nearby reserves.
Residential schools used small
handcuffs. Or those that took Native children to the schools used them.
He says that the United States has
had worse leaders than Trump.
White hadn’t known what Rupert’s
Land was.
Niagara Falls was an important
meeting place for Indigenous nations. He says it’s Seneca and Cayuga territory.
He mentions that some people are
hoping Harry and Megan will become the king and queen of Canada.
White hadn’t known that “MP” meant
“member of parliament”.
He’s been craving fish because it’s
now the traditional fishing season.
There is a false notion that school
is free for Native Canadians.
Indigenous nations had mechanisms
for absorbing outsiders, such as the two-row wampum.
White says that he is Indian on his
father’s Mohawk side but his mother’s Seneca side doesn’t recognize him as
Indian. Communities decide but they are boxed in by state and federal policies.
Robin always sits in the back row.
She called out that she is 75% Ojibwa but her daughter can’t get status unless
Robin changes her identification to her father’s information and her father was
reluctant to provide it. In the meantime her daughter can still self-identify.
Some communities are reluctant to
bring in new members because there is limited land. Some want people to move
away if they marry someone from outside. Family is important and status does
not define you.
White identifies as Mohawk but only
acknowledges his Seneca side.
In tutorial Safia once again had no
new lesson plan and merely fell back on nostalgia to read her lecture notes on
the Métis from when she taught the course.
The Métis were also called Mixed
Bloods, Half Caste, Home Guard Indians, Country Born Indians, Rupert’s
Islanders and Half Breed. It implies that there are pure or real races. Race is
linked to identity but there are no races. Belief in race is an effective tool.
She said the word “race” comes from a French word meaning “mixed”. That’s not
true. It actually means, “fixed”. It comes from “ratio” as in “generation” and
means generated from the same family.
White had used the term “domestic
dependant nations” and Safia said that term was new to her. It’s a United
States term relating to nations being wards of the federal government.
She wanted to show us a clip about
Louis Riel but there is no tech in our tutorial room.
The Métis language is Michif.
Who is legally Métis? One has to be
associated with Métis culture.
Metis are also called Bois Brûlé. It
means burnt wood, charred wood or burnt sticks. Safia says the Ojibwa called
them “where a fire has gone through”. The Ojibwe dictionary said the word for
Métis is Wiisaakodewinini. The Canadian Encyclopaedia says Bois Brûlé referred
to their skin colour.
Ward Churchill said, “Don’t let
anyone name you.” Names are cultural choices.
For the French fur traders alliances
and kinship were critical. Indigenous women knew how to trap, make snowshoes,
gather food, prepare meals and medicines.
“À la façon du pay” was the term for common-law marriage between
French fur traders and Indigenous women.
The Red River was the hub of the fur
trade.
The word Métis in the 19th
Century meant many things.
Thomas Selkirk sponsored immigrant
settlements at the Red River colony.
The aboriginal side of the Métis was
mostly Cree or Ojibwa.
The Battle of Seven Oaks after the
Pemmican Proclamation crystallized the Métis.
Where the Assiniboine and Red Rivers
meet was the hub of the Métis community.
Cuthbert Grant was Métis leader.
Red River carts were made from buffalo
hide and wood.
The merger of HBC with Northwest
Company. They were fierce competitors but after NW got charged with murder they
began to lose business and so in 1821 they were forced to merge with HBC.
Indigenous women were marrying
Europeans and country marriages were turned off. It was known by both parties
that these unions were not necessarily permanent and could be dissolved by
either half anytime. The men often already had wives back in Europe. Later it
became more desirable to marry children of Indigenous women and European men
and thus Métis culture was born.
Sir George Simpson was the governor
of HBC and through his country wife Margaret Taylor he had two children. Then
by his Métis washerwoman Betsy Sinclair he had several children.
Country marriages were annulled
after bringing back wives from Europe.
Then Safia talked about half black
and East Indian people of the Caribbean and how they became a separate class
called Douglas. The racist tradition in the Caribbean is “marry your mix”.
The Métis asked that the HBC charter
be revoked.
The buffalo declined. Riel prevented
surveyors and set up Métis government and bill of rights. HBC lost authority.
Orangeman Thomas Scott was one of the surveyors was part of the resistance to
Riel and was hung while a prisoner.
The railroad was completed bring
more settlers and the NWMP.
Riel cut the telegraph.
The Cree and Sioux joined the Métis
against the government in the Battle of Batoche. While Riel was a fugitive he
was elected three times to the House of Commons. He came to think of himself as
a divine leader and prophet. At this point Catholics that had supported him
began to reject him. He is seen as both insane and a hero.
Riel was hung on November 16, 1885.
Eight more were hung the next day. Many fled north or south and changed their
names. Riel is a francophone folk hero. He is given more scholarly attention
than anyone in Canada.
Gabriel Dumont was the second most
famous Métis leader.
In 1996 a statue of Riel was
unveiled in front of the Manitoba Legislature. Another more controversial
statue of Riel showing him naked with his genitalia exposed had been unveiled
in front of the Saskatchewan Legislature in 1968 but removed in 1991.
John Ralston Saul says that Canada
is unique in that it is comprised of three nations that are willing to
compromise with one another. He says Canada has been influenced and shaped by
Aboriginal ideas. He says that not Indigenous Canadians need to understand that
influence in order to understand themselves.
In 1870 Canada devised a system of
scrip that issued documents redeemable for land or money. It was given to Métis
in exchange for land rights. They could redeem them for land elsewhere but most
of the land was hundreds of kilometres away from their native territory. If one
took the treaty they became Indian but if they took the scrip they became
white. The Métis chose cash over the land that was offered.
What is an elder? Elders are the
gatekeepers of wisdom, knowledge and history. They are informal but respected
educators.
What is a band? Bands were groups of
families that lived and worked together. The word now describes a local
administrative unit. Nowadays the words tribe, nation and band are often
interchangeable but Indigenous communities prefer the term “First Nations”.
In 1929 the Métis wanted treaty
status. It’s still before the courts.
The Métis National Council represents the Métis.
The Métis National Council represents the Métis.
Métis father and son charged in 1993
for killing a moose. In 1998 a court ruled the Métis have a right to hunt.
The Métis population of Ontario is
120, 585.
After tutorial I went to Freshco
where I bought raspberries, strawberries, two bags of grapes and two bags of
cherries. They had whole chickens for just over $5. A woman was commenting to
me about how big and cheap they were. I agreed that it was a good price and
said that whole chickens cut up at home taste so much better than those cut up
in the store. She said she wanted to get one for her sister because she knows
her sister wouldn’t come down to get one. I said, “It’s a perfect gift!” I also
grabbed a bag of barbecue flavour sunflower seeds and two containers of Greek
yogourt.
I took the checkout aisle with the
male cashier because the line-ups were long and he tends to be faster. He
always says “Not too shabby” when asked how he is, so this time I responded,
“So, just a little shabby?” He answered, “A little bit.” “Just shabby enough?”
“That’s it!”
When I was opening my door my
neighbour Benji came out to inform me that Coffeetime has a sign downstairs
announcing they will be closing on January 26. That’s a Sunday so I assume
they’ll be open then and close for good when they lock up that night.
I had a late lunch of tuna with
green salsa and a bowl of salt and vinegar chips.
I worked on tying my lecture notes.
In the early evening I got a message
from my nephew Aaron telling me that my sister Sibyl died at 16:25 that day.
She was only four years older than me and the cancer arrived two years ago.
I had three small potatoes, a
sautéed yellow pepper, two chicken drumsticks and gravy while watching an
episode of Sugarfoot from the 1950s.
It had downloaded a while ago after several months but I’d been waiting
until it uploaded an equal amount to the download so I could delete it and feel
that I’d done a fair job as a torrent user.
I might have watched Sugarfoot as a kid but I only vaguely remember
that the show existed. It’s unique in that Tom Brewster is not a tough cowboy
like most western TV show heroes. He has a heart of gold and he is extremely
honourable. He is also studying to be a lawyer through correspondence school.
His noble efforts usually fail up until a triumphant moment when he rises to
the occasion in the end. He is called Sugarfoot because does not seem at first
glance to be very capable.
In this story Tom goes to the ranch of Cash Billings who was a good
friend of Tom’s father when Tom’s father was sheriff of the town. Tom had heard
so much about the Billings ranch from his dad that he would like to work there.
Tom finds Cash Billings to be a bitter recluse now since his daughter Anne
accidentally killed his beloved son Mark in a hunting accident. He has allowed
his ranch to be run by a no account named Fulton and his gang of thugs, who are
secretly selling off the cattle and keeping the money. They have also put up
fences that keep local people from watering their livestock, while Cash had
left the land open. Meanwhile Anne lives a lonely life in which she is hated by
her father and harassed by Fulton. Tom goes to see Cash in his bedroom where he
lies in bed brooding. At first Cash tells Tom to go away but on hearing that
Tom’s father was his old friend he lets him have a job as long as he never
comes to talk to him again. Tom is teased a lot by the hired hands and when
Fulton discovers that Tom has a gun in his saddlebag he tells him to put it on
so they can have a quick-draw contest. Fulton easily outdraws Tom and Tom just
says his gun wasn’t loaded anyway. When later Tom realizes that Fulton and his
men are up to no good he talks to Anne about it. She pleads for him to save
himself and go away. He tries to talk to Cash about it but is told to go away.
Finally Tom organizes a meeting in the town. But Fulton and his men crash and
break up the meeting. Then they beat Tom up very badly. Anne makes one last
attempt to appeal to her father but when he pushes her away she attempts to
leave. Fulton stops her and looks like he may be about to rape her when Cash
comes out and confronts him with a rifle. Tom arrives and challenges Fulton and
easily outdraws him, explaining that this time his gun was loaded. Tom stays on
at the ranch.
No comments:
Post a Comment